A man charged in the 2023 stabbing death of a former Columbus Monthly editor in her University District home has been returned to Ohio and booked into the Franklin County jail, more than three years after he first faced charges, The Columbus Dispatch reported on November 20, 2026.
Michael J. Brooks II, 31, of Columbus’s Southeast Side, was booked into the jail on November 19, 2026, according to The Columbus Dispatch. He faces two counts each of murder, aggravated murder and aggravated robbery, all as a violent offender, along with evidence tampering and escape, according to Franklin County Common Pleas Court records cited by the Dispatch. An arraignment is set for November 25, 2026.
Emily Foster, 77, was found dead in the kitchen of her home on the 2000 block of Iuka Avenue on September 9, 2023, The Columbus Dispatch reported. A neighbor who had a key let herself in at about 3:55 PM to check on Foster and found her on the kitchen floor; she had been stabbed, according to a 911 call the Dispatch obtained at the time. Foster had lived in the home for 50 years.
Foster was an editor for several magazines, including Columbus Monthly, and the author of several books, including one about the University District and its history, The Columbus Dispatch reported. She also worked at Steiner-Lesic Communications and at Ohio State University in the communications field.
Columbus police arrested Brooks on September 13, 2023 in Georgia, where they said he was hospitalized for injuries sustained in an unrelated incident, according to The Columbus Dispatch. He was then charged in Fayette County, Georgia with home invasion, burglary and theft, according to online court records cited by the Dispatch; that case was resolved on June 11, 2026, clearing the way for his return to Ohio.
Court records cited by The Columbus Dispatch also show Brooks had been released from jail four days before Foster’s death on a $10,000 recognizance bond, after an arrest in what police said was a stolen vehicle the same day he pleaded guilty to failing to comply with a police officer. He had previously served nearly five years in prison for aggravated robbery, according to the Dispatch’s reporting of court records.
What happens next is the November 25, 2026 arraignment in Franklin County Common Pleas Court, where Brooks will formally answer the murder, aggravated murder and aggravated robbery charges in Foster’s death. The charges are allegations, and Brooks is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Photo: Ɱ, CC BY-SA 4.0

