Accessibility:
Text size
Fri. Nov 20th, 2026
Delaware County Courthouse in Delaware, OhioThe Delaware County Courthouse in Delaware, Ohio. Photo: Christopher L. Riley, CC BY-SA

Delaware County still does not know who won its open county commissioner seat, and the fight now turns on 583 provisional ballots — more than the 423 votes separating the two candidates — after the county board of elections deadlocked 2-2 this week and sent the decision to Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose, the Delaware Source reported.

The board met Tuesday to work through provisional ballots from the November 3, 2026 general election and voted to count 1,400 of them, the Delaware Source reported. Of those, 526 were cast at the board of elections office on Election Day, and 874 came from voters who had moved within Delaware County but had not updated their registration to their new precinct before the 30-day deadline. Those ballots, along with 42 military, overseas and absentee ballots, were added to the interim canvass.

Counting them narrowed the race without changing its leader. Republican Renee Vaughan still leads Democrat Ryan Grissinger, but her margin shrank from 514 votes in the final unofficial election-night results to 423 votes, the Delaware Source reported — a margin that still makes an automatic recount necessary once the results are official.

The 583 ballots still in dispute came from a different group of voters: people who moved to Delaware County from another Ohio county, did not update their registration before the deadline, and then voted provisionally at their neighborhood polling places on Election Day, according to the Delaware Source. Because 583 is larger than the 423-vote margin, whether those ballots count could decide who takes the seat being vacated by retiring Commissioner Barb Lewis.

The board split along party lines. Republican members Steve Cuckler and Jessica Miller voted against counting the ballots, while Democratic members Ed Helvey and Peg Watkins voted to count them, the Delaware Source reported. The tie vote sent the question to LaRose for guidance and a final decision, and it left the official canvass incomplete — delaying the automatic recount that had initially been scheduled for next week.

The legal argument against counting them was laid out in a letter sent to the board Monday by Christopher Slagle, a partner at the Columbus law firm Bricker Graydon Wyatt LLP, and obtained by the Delaware Source. “We respectfully ask request the board to reject that category of provisional ballots because Ohio law makes the location of casting an express condition of a county-to-county mover’s eligibility to vote in the election,” Slagle wrote, citing Ohio Revised Code 3503.16(C). Attorney Ryan L. Richardson of the same firm attended Tuesday’s meeting representing Vaughan, who was also present, the Delaware Source reported.

Helvey, the board chair, pushed back with a different section of state law, pointing to Ohio Revised Code 3505.181, specifically sections (B)(3) and (B)(4), which address transferring provisional ballots and voter information to election officials for verification, the Delaware Source reported. The law states that if the appropriate local election official determines the individual is eligible to vote, “the individual’s provisional ballot shall be counted as a vote in that election.” “So, it seems to be in direct conflict to what you’re saying,” Helvey told Richardson, according to the Delaware Source.

Watkins pointed to the secretary of state’s handbook for boards of elections, which she said indicates provisional voting may take place on Election Day at the board of elections office or at a voter’s correct polling location, the Delaware Source reported. “I’m thinking that if this is how the secretary of state interpreted that, I would go with what they have to say,” Watkins said, according to the Delaware Source. Richardson responded that “a directive cannot trump the plain language of a statute,” the Delaware Source reported.

Advertise your business here

Helvey also raised a fairness question: Delaware County once required provisional voters to visit the board office, but in more recent years it has allowed them to cast provisional ballots at polling locations, he said, according to the Delaware Source. “To say now that we’ve done things wrong for a number of years and have counted votes that were improper is one thing,” Helvey said, according to the Delaware Source. “But the other thing, too, is I don’t want to have to spin on our heads and say, we’re gonna disenfranchise people that did exactly what they were told to do.”

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on. What is confirmed: 1,400 provisional ballots have been counted, Vaughan leads Grissinger by 423 votes, 583 ballots from voters who moved into the county remain uncounted, and the board is tied 2-2. What is still open: whether LaRose directs the board to count or reject those 583 ballots, when the canvass can be completed and certified, and when the automatic recount — already necessary at this margin — will actually run. The same location question is also being litigated in northwest Ohio, where a House race turned on a similar challenge; Wood County has already certified its November 3 results as a recount was set. Delaware County’s elections office is separately in the headlines this week after a former board member’s lawyer accused LaRose of colluding with Democrats in a different Delaware County dispute.

What happens next is already on the calendar. The board is scheduled to meet again at 4 p.m. Monday to continue the official canvass, with LaRose’s guidance expected to help resolve the dispute over the remaining 583 ballots, the Delaware Source reported. Ohio’s county boards must complete their canvasses by November 24, 2026, after which the secretary of state reviews county results and formally certifies the election. Only after Delaware County certifies can the automatic recount in the commissioner race proceed.

Photo: Christopher L. Riley, CC BY-SA

By Dan Whitmore

Dan Whitmore covers Ohio politics and elections for NewsForce247 — the Statehouse, statewide races, and the county boards of elections where Ohio voting actually runs. Through November, his byline leads our Election 2026 coverage in every county.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *