Accessibility:
Text size
Fri. Nov 20th, 2026
The downtown Columbus, Ohio skyline and the Main Street Bridge over the Scioto River under a partly cloudy skyDowntown Columbus from the Main Street Bridge.

A new Franklin County study is asking Columbus-area leaders to look harder at the long-term bill for the property tax breaks they hand out to spur housing development, finding that the revenue cities and schools give up during an abatement can take years — sometimes decades — to earn back after the break expires.

The findings come from Franklin County’s Tax Incentive Review Council report for 2026, covered this week by The Columbus Dispatch. The council reviews the county’s tax incentive programs each year, and this year’s report focused on Community Reinvestment Area abatements, the breaks offered in designated areas to developers who build new housing or renovate existing buildings.

The report draws on an analysis by economists Mark Partridge, an Ohio State University professor emeritus, and Nick Messinger, a senior researcher at the Ohio River Valley Institute, according to The Columbus Dispatch. The pair examined 2,140 residential properties whose CRA abatements expired between 2014 and 2025.

They found that homes with recently expired abatements sold for roughly 12.3 percent more than comparable homes in the year the incentives expired — but that premium disappeared within three years, The Columbus Dispatch reported. Property tax revenue did rise after the breaks ended, by about $1,515 a year for the average property and $162 for the median property, but the researchers concluded that the added revenue does not immediately make taxing authorities whole.

“This underscores the importance of evaluating tax abatements not only by the amount of investment they attract but also by their long-term implications for the public revenues that support schools, local governments, and community services,” the report states, in a passage quoted by The Columbus Dispatch.

The study also looked at what happened to the neighborhoods that received the most CRA investment. Those areas were more likely to see household incomes and educational attainment rise — and the share of non-white residents fall — over time, according to the Dispatch’s account of the research. The economists said the findings do not prove abatements caused those changes, but that they are consistent with broader patterns of neighborhood change and gentrification, in which rising values can strengthen a neighborhood while also pricing out the people who already live there.

“These conclusions do not establish that residential tax abatements are inherently beneficial or harmful,” the report states, as quoted by The Columbus Dispatch. “Rather, they reinforce the importance of carefully considering the purpose, structure, and long-term consequences of these incentives.”

The scale of the incentives in Franklin County is large. Per the 2026 council report, as summarized by The Columbus Dispatch, reviewers examined 345 abated projects; the county carried 1,176 commercial CRA abatements and 7,277 residential CRA abatements, with $225,013,930 in foregone tax from commercial CRA and Enterprise Zone abatements. Tax Increment Financing districts covered 29,792 parcels — up 6 percent from last year — and diverted $195,661,054, up 30 percent.

Advertise your business here

The report lands in the middle of a wider Ohio argument about what tax breaks buy. A separate study covered by NewsForce247 this fall found data center tax breaks cost Ohio schools $374 million in 2025, and Franklin County itself continues to pair incentives with direct housing investment, including $3 million the county put toward a 54-unit senior housing project in Columbus.

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on: The council’s 2026 report and the Partridge-Messinger analysis are public, and their central finding is narrow — abatements raise values and eventual revenue, but the payback period is long and uncertain because it depends on future values and tax rates. What is not yet known is whether Columbus, Franklin County, or area school boards will change how they approve, size, or time-limit CRA deals in response.

Supporters of abatements have long argued that much of the development they subsidize would not happen at all without an incentive — the “but for” test — and the study does not claim to settle that argument. It does give skeptics fresh numbers: a sale-price premium that fades within three years, and a median post-abatement revenue gain of $162 a year against years of taxes forgone.

What happens next is a policy choice, not a finding. The Tax Incentive Review Council’s reports are advisory, so any change would come through the Columbus City Council, county commissioners, and school boards that approve individual deals. Readers weighing a specific project can start with the same question the researchers posed: not just how much investment a break attracts, but how long the public waits to be repaid.

By Grant Ellison

Grant Ellison covers Ohio business and agriculture — Main Street storefronts, manufacturers, grain markets, and the farm economy that feeds the state.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *