Accessibility:
Text size
Fri. Nov 20th, 2026
Delaware City Hall in Delaware, OhioDelaware City Hall in Delaware, Ohio. (Public domain photo via Wikimedia Commons)

The fight over a former Delaware County elections official’s voter registration has escalated into a criminal referral, and her attorney is now accusing Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose of working with Democrats to punish her. Scott Pullins, an election law attorney from Mount Vernon representing Melanie Leneghan, said in a press release shared November 19, 2026 with The Columbus Dispatch that LaRose is conducting “political lawfare” and “colluded” with Democrats against the former Republican member of the Delaware County Board of Elections.

LaRose’s office has referred Leneghan for criminal prosecution, accusing the former GOP state central committee member of voting illegally and false voter registration, The Columbus Dispatch reported. The Delaware County Prosecutor’s Office has transferred the criminal referral to the Ohio Attorney General’s Office, which did not immediately respond to a request for comment, according to The Columbus Dispatch.

The Secretary of State’s office pushed back on the collusion claim. “This case is now in the hands of the Ohio Attorney General,” Dan Lusheck, a spokesperson for the Ohio Secretary of State’s Office, told The Columbus Dispatch. “Ms. Leneghan’s attorney should focus his time on making his arguments there.”

The dispute began with a residency challenge. Another Delaware County Republican, Velva Dunn, who defeated Leneghan for a seat on the Delaware GOP Central Committee in 2024, filed a challenge in February 2026 alleging that Leneghan had moved to South Carolina, The Columbus Dispatch reported. Leneghan sold her home in Powell in January 2025 and changed her voter registration to her best friend’s house in Galena in December 2025, a home she now co-owns. She owns two homes in South Carolina, where her daughter attends college, but told The Columbus Dispatch earlier this year that her cars are registered in Ohio and that she pays out-of-state tuition and taxes in South Carolina.

In April 2026, the Delaware County Board of Elections voted 2-1 to cancel Leneghan’s voter registration and her candidacy for reelection to the Ohio GOP State Central Committee, with the board’s two Democrats voting in favor of cancellation and Leneghan recusing herself, according to The Columbus Dispatch. She appealed to the Ohio Supreme Court, which unanimously rejected her case in May 2026, and she was removed from the board of elections after the appeal.

Pullins argued that LaRose’s office had “fully vetted” Leneghan when it appointed her to the Delaware County Board of Elections in 2025, and that any potential issues could have been picked up at that time, The Columbus Dispatch reported. The appointment was controversial from the start: the Delaware County Republican Party’s executive committee had initially nominated Leneghan among at least seven other candidates in a private vote, and critics were already raising concerns about her residency after the sale of the home she had owned since 2007, as well as her past association with misleading mailers from a political action committee.

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on

What is confirmed: the registration cancellation, the unanimous Ohio Supreme Court rejection of Leneghan’s appeal, her removal from the board, and the transfer of the criminal referral from Delaware County prosecutors to the Ohio Attorney General. What is not yet known: whether the Attorney General’s office will bring charges, and what evidence beyond the residency dispute the referral contains. The Attorney General’s office had not commented as of The Columbus Dispatch’s November 20, 2026 report.

Pullins told The Columbus Dispatch the investigation and any prosecution are “a colossal waste of taxpayers dollars,” saying Leneghan travels frequently for work and was caring for her elderly mother in 2025 and 2026 following a heart attack. “At the time she was removed from the ballot and her registration canceled, she owned a residence in Delaware County and registered and voted according to Ohio law,” Pullins said in the release shared with The Columbus Dispatch. “But Frank LaRose continues to punish her for being responsible.”

Advertise your business here

The case lands as LaRose himself changes offices. LaRose was the only Republican to win statewide office in the November 3, 2026 election, according to The Columbus Dispatch; term-limited as secretary of state, he ran a successful campaign for state auditor and will lead that office in January 2027. NewsForce247 covered his plans for that office earlier today: LaRose wants the auditor’s office to inspect voter rolls; Russo calls it a power grab. Delaware County’s own November 3 ballot was introduced in our first-pass election coverage: Delaware County voters weighed three countywide levies on the November 3 ballot.

What happens next is in Columbus, not Delaware: the Ohio Attorney General’s office will decide whether the referral becomes a criminal case. Until that decision is announced, Leneghan remains off the elections board, her registration canceled, and her attorney’s collusion charge unanswered beyond the Secretary of State’s brief response.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *