WHITEHALL, Ohio — Whitehall Police Chief Mike Crispen will retire as chief effective December 18, 2026, and Safety Director Van Gregg will retire effective December 31, 2026, with Crispen then stepping in temporarily as safety director, NBC4 (WCMH) reported.
Mayor Michael Bivens confirmed both dates to NBC4 and said he learned recently, but separately, about the two departures. Bivens asked Crispen to serve as safety director once Gregg vacates the position, and said he is unsure how long Crispen will serve in that role, according to NBC4.
The safety director is a cabinet-level position appointed by the mayor, unlike the police chief, who is hired by the city, and the director oversees the police department and other public safety agencies for Whitehall, NBC4 reported. Bivens told NBC4 that Crispen agreed to step in for reasons of institutional integrity, retention of institutional knowledge and continuity of service.
Crispen was hired as chief in 2016, after joining Whitehall following a career with the Ohio State Highway Patrol, according to the City of Whitehall staff directory and NBC4 reporting. Gregg, a former Whitehall city councilman, was appointed safety director in 2018, first as an interim appointee who became the full-time director, NBC4 reported.
Bivens has largely stood by Crispen amid controversy over his leadership, NBC4 reported. NBC4 Investigates found that from 2022 to 2025, crime in Whitehall fell by 47 percent under Crispen, while 39 officers left the division citing a toxic work environment, and in January the president of Fraternal Order of Police Lodge Nine told Whitehall City Council that every patrol officer had voted no-confidence in Crispen, according to NBC4. Crispen has defended his leadership and denied allegations of a poor environment, and the city has declined to investigate the culture on the force, NBC4 reported.
Bivens denied to NBC4 that the arrangement was a backroom deal, saying it was predicated on continuity of service and performance, and that there was no joint discussion between the two men about a shuffling of positions, according to NBC4.
What happens next is the police chief transition. Bivens told NBC4 he does not yet know who will serve as interim police chief, but will have a plan in place by December 18, 2026, when Crispen retirement as chief takes effect. Whitehall residents will learn the interim chief name and the expected length of Crispen service as safety director from City Hall in the coming weeks.

