Quick Takeaways
- U.S. Paper Mill has restored pumping to hold back the Wear-Ever toxic plume under Chillicothe after a pump shaft fractured in Well 18, shifting to the dormant Well 17.
- Ohio EPA told 10TV there is “no immediate risk of the plume migrating,” as reported by State Wonderer.
- Containment still rests on one well at a time, and the company says the pumping costs at least $1 million a year to run.
Water is being pumped again to hold back a decades-old toxic groundwater plume under Chillicothe after a pump failure last week at U.S. Paper Mill, the company said in an update on November 16, 2026, reported by the Chillicothe Gazette.
U.S. Paper Mill said a decades-old shaft fractured in Well 18, which had been used to pump water to contain the plume, and that because the shaft could not be repaired quickly, the company shifted to using Well 17, which had been dormant, according to its news release as reported by the Chillicothe Gazette. The company said the water table level is being maintained.
The plume is the leftover pollution of the WearEver Aluminum factory, which made cookware in Chillicothe from 1948 until the late 1990s. According to an Ohio EPA fact sheet cited by State Wonderer, waste from the plant left chlorinated solvents such as trichloroethylene (TCE), along with lead, cadmium and other metals, in the soil and groundwater.
Howmet Aerospace, the current owner of the Wear-Ever property, is responsible for controlling the contamination, State Wonderer reported. For decades, the paper mill next door pumped large amounts of groundwater for its operations, and two of those wells — 17 and 18 — also helped keep the contaminated water from spreading.
U.S. Paper Mill bought the closed Pixelle Specialty Solutions plant last year and has kept pumping since, which it describes in its release as a voluntary service to Ohio EPA and Howmet, the Chillicothe Gazette reported. The company said it alerted Ohio EPA and the City of Chillicothe when the fracture occurred.
The Scioto Post reported that the company’s crew switched to a pump on Well 17 and worked several hours to weld its shaft and get it running, pumping at least 500 gallons a minute to keep the water table under control. Utilities Superintendent Aaron Anders described the repair at a November 16, 2026, open house in Chillicothe, the Scioto Post reported.
What we know — and what we’re still waiting on
What we know: Well 18’s shaft fractured, Well 17 is running in its place, and the water table is being maintained, according to the company’s November 16, 2026, release. Ohio EPA told 10TV there is “no immediate risk of the plume migrating” despite the fracture, State Wonderer reported. What we’re still waiting on: how long Well 17 will carry containment on its own, and whether the longer-term fix is a repaired Well 18, a new well, or a different arrangement between Howmet and Ohio EPA.
The June 2026 groundwater monitoring record shows how thin the margin has been. Key Environmental Inc., Howmet’s environmental consultant, wrote in its second-quarter 2026 report to Ohio EPA that Collector Well 17 was not operating during the June monitoring event and that U.S. Paper Mill had been running Well 18 alone since taking ownership, J News Network reported.
The company says employees make hourly rounds every shift to check the wells and that the pumps cost at least $1 million per year to operate, according to its release as reported by J News Network. Its commitments also include receiving and processing leachate from the Paint Street Landfill and keeping the former plant in compliance with state water and air permits.
Residents with questions can contact Ohio EPA’s Southeast District Office in Logan, which oversees the site, State Wonderer reported. NewsForce247 has also covered health and development news across the region, including the E. coli investigation at Ohio University in Athens and new apartment construction in Zanesville.
What happens next is a repair timeline: U.S. Paper Mill must either fix Well 18’s fractured shaft or keep Well 17 running reliably, while Ohio EPA and Howmet — the party responsible for the plume — decide whether one working well is enough to keep the contamination where it sits.


