Accessibility:
Text size
Fri. Nov 20th, 2026
The Pike County Courthouse, a red-brick courthouse with a gold dome in Waverly, OhioThe Pike County Courthouse in Waverly, Ohio. Photo: Nyttend, public domain

A Pike County special grand jury has declined to indict the two officers who shot a Chillicothe man during a November 11, 2026 encounter on State Route 335, and has instead indicted the man himself on seven counts, Pike County Prosecuting Attorney Michael A. Davis announced on Friday, November 20, 2026, according to J News Network’s report of the prosecutor’s announcement.

The shooting happened on State Route 335 near Walkers Ridge in Pike County at about 3:30 PM on November 11, 2026, according to the prosecutor’s office, as reported by J News Network. J News Network previously reported that Pike County deputies shot Anthony D. Umphries, 56, of Chillicothe, after a foot pursuit near Beaver.

The Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation’s Force Investigation Unit investigated the officers’ actions, which the prosecutor’s office said is standard procedure in all officer-involved shootings, according to J News Network. The grand jury reviewed body-camera footage showing Umphries firing at the officers before they returned fire, photographs of the scene, an interview with Umphries, and testimony from investigators and the officers before returning the no bills, according to the prosecutor’s office, as reported by J News Network.

A no bill means the grand jury did not find sufficient grounds to charge the officers for firing their weapons in the encounter. The decision closes the criminal review of the two officers’ conduct in the November 11, 2026 shooting, on the evidence the prosecutor’s office said the grand jury heard: the body-camera footage, the scene photographs, the defendant’s own interview and the testimony.

In a separate decision, the grand jury returned a true bill against Umphries on seven counts: two counts of attempted aggravated murder, two counts of felonious assault, aggravated trafficking in drugs, aggravated possession of drugs, and having weapons while under disability, according to the prosecutor’s office, as reported by J News Network. The drug counts allege 60 grams of methamphetamine, the prosecutor’s release said, according to J News Network.

The indictment also carries firearm specifications on six counts and repeat-violent-offender specifications on four counts, according to the prosecutor’s office, as reported by J News Network. Specifications matter at sentencing: if Umphries is convicted, they can add mandatory prison time on top of the sentences for the underlying counts.

A grand jury does not decide guilt or innocence. Its job is to decide whether the evidence supports bringing charges at all — a true bill sends a case forward to trial court, while a no bill ends the matter. In officer-involved shootings, that screening role is why the BCI investigation and the body-camera footage matter so much: the grand jurors in Pike County were asked to judge the deputies’ split-second decisions against the full record the investigators assembled, not against the first reports from the scene.

The encounter itself began as a foot pursuit near Beaver, J News Network previously reported, and ended on State Route 335 near Walkers Ridge, the prosecutor’s office said. State Route 335 is one of Pike County’s main north-south corridors, running from the Waverly area south toward the Scioto County line, and the stretch near Walkers Ridge is a rural two-lane section where a mid-afternoon shooting on November 11, 2026 drew the county’s full investigative response.

Advertise your business here

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on: Confirmed by the prosecutor’s announcement, as reported by J News Network, are the grand jury’s two decisions — no bills for both officers and a seven-count true bill for Umphries — the evidence the grand jury reviewed, and the 60 grams of methamphetamine alleged in the drug counts. The charges in the indictment are allegations, and Umphries is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court, the prosecutor’s office said, according to J News Network. What has not been released is the body-camera footage itself; the prosecutor’s account of what it shows is, at this stage, the public record of the encounter.

Umphries remains in custody, according to the prosecutor’s office, as reported by J News Network. For Pike County, the grand jury’s decision resolves the question that has hung over the sheriff’s office since November 11, 2026 — whether the deputies who fired would face charges — while opening the court case against the man they shot.

What happens next is the arraignment: Umphries will be arraigned before Judge Rob Junk in the Pike County Court of Common Pleas, according to the prosecutor’s office, as reported by J News Network. At arraignment the charges will be formally read, Umphries will enter a plea, and the case will be set on the court’s trial schedule.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *