Mon. Nov 16th, 2026
The Butler County Courthouse in Hamilton, OhioThe Butler County Courthouse in Hamilton. Photo: Greg Hume, CC BY

A Middletown man accused of killing his girlfriend and placing her body in the trunk of an SUV pleaded not guilty on Monday, Nov. 16, in Butler County Common Pleas Court, where a judge set his bond at $1.5 million, The Cincinnati Enquirer reported.

Darwin Malcom, 51, is charged with a dozen felony counts, including murder, kidnapping, tampering with evidence and gross abuse of a corpse, according to The Enquirer. He entered his plea at an arraignment before Judge Michael Oster Jr. and is being held at the Butler County Jail awaiting trial.

Authorities say Malcom shot and killed Samantha Kelly, 43, on Nov. 5 at the couple’s apartment on Tytus Avenue in Middletown, The Enquirer reported. Middletown police found Kelly in the back of a Chevrolet Tahoe after officers were called to the apartment complex that afternoon for a welfare check.

Butler County Assistant Prosecutor Katherine Pridemore said in court that Kelly’s coworkers visited the apartment twice that day out of concern for her well-being, according to The Enquirer. Prosecutors told the court that video and an admission show the killing was not an accident, and that Malcom planned to flee with Kelly’s body before police could arrest him, The Enquirer reported.

The details prosecutors laid out at the arraignment frame the case the state intends to prove: that the shooting inside the Tytus Avenue apartment was deliberate, and that the effort to move Kelly’s body into the Tahoe was part of an attempt to leave before officers arrived.

The charges reflect both the killing itself and what prosecutors say happened afterward. Alongside murder and kidnapping, the tampering-with-evidence and gross-abuse-of-a-corpse counts track the state’s account of Kelly’s body being moved into the Tahoe, as prosecutors described it in court and The Enquirer reported. Malcom has not entered any plea beyond not guilty, and the case remains at its earliest stage.

Malcom’s not-guilty plea means the dozen counts will now move through the Common Pleas Court process, with pretrial hearings ahead of any trial date. The $1.5 million bond set by Judge Oster keeps him in the Butler County Jail in the meantime.

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on

What is confirmed from Monday’s court proceedings, as The Enquirer reported: Malcom is charged with 12 felony counts including murder, pleaded not guilty, and is held on $1.5 million bond. What is not yet public: a trial schedule, and the full evidence — including the video prosecutors referenced — that the state expects to present.

What happens next: Malcom is expected to return to court on Jan. 11, The Enquirer reported, as the case proceeds toward trial in Butler County Common Pleas Court.

Photo: Greg Hume, CC BY

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *