Accessibility:
Text size
Fri. Nov 20th, 2026
Panoramic view over Chillicothe, Ohio, toward downtownChillicothe, seen in a panoramic view. Photo: Nyttend, public domain

Containment of the Wear-Ever toxic plume beneath Chillicothe now rests on a single collector well, after the well that had been doing the work alone broke down and a dormant well was brought back online to replace it. U.S. Paper Mill said in a November 16, 2026, release, as reported by the Chillicothe Gazette, that a decades-old shaft fractured in Collector Well 18, the well it had been pumping to hold the water table down and keep the plume from rising or spreading. Because the shaft could not be repaired quickly, the company shifted pumping to Collector Well 17, which had been sitting dormant.

The company said the water table level is being maintained and that it alerted the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency and the City of Chillicothe when the fracture occurred. The Chillicothe Gazette reported on November 12, 2026, that the company had alerted Ohio EPA that day to a pump fracture on a roughly 90-foot pump in a containment well, a failure the Gazette described as raising concerns about the plume beneath the city.

Advertise your business here

The November 16, 2026, release filled in a gap in the company’s first statement. As J News Network reported on November 13, 2026, the November 12, 2026, statement called the failure a “potentially urgent situation” but never named a well. The later release identified the broken shaft as Well 18’s and confirmed the switch to Well 17, and J News Network’s review of the state filings showed the switch matters because Well 18 had been working alone: Key Environmental Inc., Howmet Aerospace’s environmental consultant, stated in the former Wear-Ever site’s second-quarter 2026 groundwater monitoring report that “Collector Well 17 was not operating during this monitoring event,” describing the June 2026 monitoring, and that U.S. Paper Mill “has continued to operate Collector Well 18 since taking ownership of the property.”

“I am grateful to all our colleagues who prioritized the health and safety of the community we love over the operations of our business,” utility superintendent Aaron Anders said in the company’s release, as reported by the Chillicothe Gazette. “We are pleased to see that the well water is being pumped, and we will continue to monitor the situation, as we always have.” The company said employees make hourly rounds to check the wells, that the pumps cost at least $1 million per year to operate, and that it pumps voluntarily as a service to Ohio EPA and Howmet since acquiring the closed Pixelle plant last year.

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on

What is confirmed comes from the documents: the June 2026 monitoring report filed with Ohio EPA shows one well running; the company’s own releases confirm that well’s shaft fractured and that pumping moved to the dormant well; and Ohio EPA raised containment concerns as far back as July 7, 2025, when it wrote to Howmet about “groundwater containment concerns and additional monitoring well installation due to the anticipated shutdown of the paper mill,” according to the same monitoring report. What is not yet established is the pumping volume Well 17 is sustaining compared with what the site historically pulled, and the monitoring report itself states that U.S. Paper Mill’s “long term plans for use of the paper mill production wells are not well understood.”

The history in the state record is why volume matters. The second-quarter 2026 report, citing the 2020 Five-Year Review Report, recounts that when collector-well production was reduced in 2020, with both wells in service, groundwater flow at the site shifted to the southeast and stayed shifted through the third quarter of 2021, returning toward the east-northeast only after pumping increased again. The report states the low-pumping outcome plainly: during low or no pumping at Wells 17 and 18, groundwater beneath the site “will likely flow east-southeast toward the Scioto River.”

NBC4 Investigates reported in July 2025 that Ohio EPA documents tie earlier pumping pauses, in the 2000s and during the COVID-19 pandemic, to spikes in trichloroethylene (TCE) concentrations, that the mill’s wells historically used more than 1 billion gallons of water a year, and that Ohio EPA described the mill closing in 2022 as a “worst-case scenario” for containing the plume. Linda Weavers, codirector of the Ohio Water Resources Center at Ohio State University, told NBC4 the wells flush contaminated water out of the system, and that when pumping stops, contaminants stuck on soil have more time to interact with water and release more contamination.

The early-warning network meant to catch the plume if it moves is still not in the ground. J News Network reported on November 12, 2026, that Ohio EPA ordered additional sentinel monitoring wells, that property access agreements sent out in October 2025 remain unsigned, and that on November 6, 2026, Ohio EPA sent Howmet’s installation work plan back with nine technical comments. The company operating the site today is a glove manufacturer, an affiliate of U.S. Medical Glove Company, and J News Network has reported that a glove operation will never pull the water volume Pixelle pulled at full production. Groundwater oversight elsewhere in Ohio is drawing the same kind of scrutiny, including the state’s testing of private wells near shut-down injection wells outside Marietta, and the plume story is unfolding in the same Chillicothe that lights its Christmas tree this weekend.

What happens next runs through Ohio EPA: the sentinel-well work plan must clear the agency’s nine technical comments and the access agreements must be signed before the early-warning wells can be installed, and the broken Well 18 shaft must be repaired or replaced before the site again has a second well to fall back on. Until then, containment at the Wear-Ever plume is one well at a time, and the water table the company says it is maintaining is the number Chillicothe residents will be watching.

Photo: Nyttend, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons — panoramic view of Chillicothe.

By Jesse Tackett

Jesse Tackett is NewsForce247's general assignment reporter for Southeast Ohio, covering the river and Appalachian counties from Marietta to Portsmouth.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *