Accessibility:
Text size
Fri. Nov 20th, 2026
Welcome to Pickerington sign in Pickerington, OhioThe Pickerington welcome sign. (Public domain)

Pickerington Local Schools is turning the number that beat it into a rallying cry. More than 100 parents, students and residents gathered at Pickerington High School North on Monday, November 16, 2026, for the launch of Project 256, the district’s effort to rebuild support after its November 3, 2026 income tax levy failed by exactly 256 votes, according to the Columbus Dispatch. The loss was immediate in its effects: the district suspended all non-varsity athletics and most extracurricular activities the day after the election, and its remaining music and theater programs are scheduled to end on December 31, 2026.

The proposal voters rejected was a 10-year, 0.75 percent earned income tax that would have raised the district’s school income tax rate from 1 percent to 1.75 percent and generated an estimated $21 million a year for the general fund, the district’s Project 256 site says. It was Pickerington’s second levy failure of 2026: a larger 1.25 percent income tax request failed by more than 26 percentage points in May 2026, and the district answered that loss with more than $5 million in budget cuts, including staffing and program reductions and higher athletic fees, the Dispatch reported.

Superintendent Charles Smialek told the November 16, 2026 meeting that Project 256 has four aims — to energize, mobilize, inform and engage the community before the board’s next decision on returning to the ballot, according to the Columbus Dispatch. The district has also opened a Student Opportunity Fund, announced in a November 16, 2026 email to families, that lets individuals, businesses and community organizations contribute toward extracurricular programs during the 2026-27 school year, the Project 256 site says. No date for a new levy request has been announced.

The community response began within days of the vote. At a marathon school board meeting on November 9, 2026, some 758 people filled the Performing Arts Center — eight over its listed capacity — and 29 students and 15 adult residents spoke over more than two and a half hours, the Dispatch reported. “Our future changed overnight,” Kylie Byers, a freshman volleyball player at Pickerington North, told the Columbus Dispatch at that meeting. Board President Cathy Olshefski called the situation “devastating” in remarks reported by the Dispatch.

Advertise your business here

Two district residents, Lisa Mann and Demetrius Ross, are starting the Pickerington Community Athletic Foundation, a nonprofit intended to restore and sustain sub-varsity athletics at both junior highs and both high schools through community funding, according to the Columbus Dispatch. The foundation effort and the district’s own fund reflect the same calculation: with 19 sports affected by the suspensions, families are looking for ways to keep younger athletes playing while the longer levy fight plays out.

Pickerington’s result was part of a statewide pattern. Only 13 percent of school district income tax levies in Ohio were approved on November 3, 2026, even though 54 percent of all levies passed, according to Ohio School Boards Association figures reported by the Columbus Dispatch. The district serves more than 11,500 students in a city of 26,333 people, and its two high schools, Pickerington North and Pickerington Central, regularly contend for regional and state championships — one reason the suspension of everything below the varsity level landed so hard.

Advertise your business here

Other Ohio districts are making the same hard arithmetic in public. In Columbus, the superintendent has taken medical leave while the district faces $50 million in cuts — read our coverage: Columbus Superintendent on Medical Leave as District Faces $50 Million in Cuts. And in Lake County, Mentor Schools will close three elementary buildings in a 2027 consolidation, detailed here: Mentor Schools Will Close Three Elementary Buildings in 2027 Consolidation.

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on

What is confirmed: the November 3, 2026 levy failed by 256 votes; non-varsity sports and most extracurriculars have been suspended since November 4, 2026; music and theater run through December 31, 2026; and the district’s reduction plan describes a second phase of cuts taking effect January 1, 2027, if new revenue is not found, according to the Project 256 site. What is not yet known: whether the board will return to voters in 2027, at what rate, and whether community fundraising can restore any suspended programs before then.

What happens next runs on two clocks. The board of education meets twice a month, on Mondays at 6 p.m. at the District Office at 90 North East Street in Pickerington, and any decision to try another levy will be made in those public sessions. The harder deadline is December 31, 2026, when the theater and music programs that survived the first round of cuts are set to end — the date Project 256 is, in effect, racing against.

One thought on “Pickerington Launches Project 256 After Levy Fails by 256 Votes; Sports Stay Cut”
  1. […] Olentangy’s predicament is the mirror image of the one playing out in neighboring districts this fall, where levy failures have forced immediate cuts. In Pickerington, where a levy failed by 256 votes on November 3, 2026, non-varsity sports remain suspended while a community group organizes the next campaign — a contrast Olentangy’s leaders are plainly working to avoid by planning years ahead of their projected shortfall. Readers can follow that story in our coverage of Pickerington’s Project 256 effort. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *