A Norwood comic book store that prosecutors say became a fence for stolen Legos, allergy medicine and whitening strips has sent its owner to prison. James Bird, 47, was sentenced Tuesday, November 17, to 3 to 4½ years in prison for running what prosecutors called a massive theft operation out of Paper Street Trading Co., the Cincinnati Enquirer reported.
Bird told Hamilton County Judge Virginia Tallent at his sentencing that he started the business nearly a decade ago "to bring joy" to people and wanted Paper Street Trading Co. to be "a safe place for people," the Enquirer reported. "This is not a reflection of the person I want to be," Bird told Judge Tallent, according to the Enquirer.
Prosecutors said the theft operation spanned at least four years, from 2020 to 2024, and was so large that officials say the cost to retailers could not be adequately measured, the Enquirer reported. The store is believed to have sold items stolen from Kroger, Walmart, Meijer, Target, Walgreens and other retailers. Investigators working from eBay and PayPal records identified suspicious transactions over the four years totaling nearly $927,000, involving products not typically sold through a comic book store and known to be frequently stolen — over-the-counter medications, calculators and Legos.
Paper Street Trading Co. sold allergy medications including Allegra, Claritin and Zyrtec, as well as Crest 3D Whitestrips, Metamucil and 23andMe DNA kits, the Enquirer reported. The business was also involved in hundreds of thousands of dollars in transactions with a California man who faced theft, conspiracy and money laundering charges in Illinois, according to the Enquirer.
When investigators searched Bird’s store in February 2024, they recovered thousands of stolen items worth more than $158,000, the Enquirer reported. Judge Tallent noted at sentencing that the goods recovered that day represented only what Bird had on a single day and did not "represent the many years you were engaged in this," according to the Enquirer.
Assistant Prosecutor Jennifer Deering said Bird had "preyed on" people suffering from drug addiction and essentially encouraged them to steal to support their drug habits, the Enquirer reported. Bird pleaded guilty in September to receiving stolen property and telecommunications fraud. In imposing the prison term, Tallent said she was "deeply troubled by the nature and scale of this criminal activity," and added, "I don’t think anybody knows the true numbers," in remarks reported by the Enquirer.
The timeline of the case stretches across most of the store’s life, as laid out in court and reported by the Cincinnati Enquirer. Bird said he opened the business nearly a decade ago. Prosecutors dated the theft operation to 2020 through 2024. Investigators searched the store in February 2024 and recovered the thousands of stolen items. Bird pleaded guilty in September 2026 to receiving stolen property and telecommunications fraud, and Judge Tallent imposed the prison sentence on November 17.
What we know — and what we’re still waiting on
What is confirmed: Bird’s September guilty pleas to receiving stolen property and telecommunications fraud; Tuesday’s sentence of 3 to 4½ years from Judge Tallent; the nearly $927,000 in suspicious eBay and PayPal transactions investigators identified; and the more than $158,000 in stolen goods recovered in the February 2024 search — all as reported by the Cincinnati Enquirer from the court proceedings and prosecutors’ statements. What remains unresolved is the full value of what passed through the store over four years, which prosecutors and the judge both said may never be fully measured.
As part of his sentence, Bird was ordered to pay restitution to the two retailers that quantified their losses: $35,000 to Kroger and $37,000 to Walmart, attributed to people known as "boosters" who prosecutors say worked with Bird’s fencing operation, the Enquirer reported.
One part of the case ends with something other than a warehouse: the Hamilton County Prosecutor’s Office, the county sheriff’s office, Kroger and Walmart are working on a plan to donate the stolen Legos recovered in the case to children in need, the Enquirer reported.
The sentencing closes a case that turned a neighborhood comic shop into the clearinghouse for a four-year shoplifting pipeline across Greater Cincinnati’s biggest retailers — one that investigators ultimately mapped not through the store’s shelves, but through its online sales records.
What happens next: Bird begins serving his 3-to-4½-year prison term, the restitution orders to Kroger and Walmart stand as part of the sentence, and the prosecutor’s office, sheriff’s office and the two retailers continue work on the plan to donate the recovered Legos to children in need.


