A Cleveland man will spend at least 27 years in prison — and possibly the rest of his life — for the 2025 shooting death of Razeil Robinson in Akron, after a Summit County judge handed down a life sentence on Tuesday, November 17, in a courtroom where the victim’s family described a year of grief, anger and, for some of them, a hard turn toward forgiveness, the Akron Beacon Journal reported.
Summit County Common Pleas Court Judge Jennifer Towell sentenced Timothy Whitthorne, 34, of Cleveland, to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 27 years, according to the Beacon Journal. A jury had previously found Whitthorne guilty of murder, felony murder, felonious assault, having weapons under disability and three firearm specifications in Robinson’s killing.
Robinson, 27, was shot and killed in the early morning hours of September 25, 2025, in Akron. Prosecutors said, in a news release reported by the Beacon Journal, that an employee parking in a lot on the 1000 block of Rosemary Boulevard found a cellphone with its flashlight still on, and that employees later found Robinson nearby in the grass as visibility improved. Investigators determined Robinson had been shot in the neck and chest, and the chest wound — which damaged his lungs and heart — proved fatal, prosecutors said.
Surveillance footage showed Whitthorne and a woman walking in the area before, during and after the shooting, the Beacon Journal reported. Akron police identified the woman, who said Whitthorne shot Robinson multiple times after Robinson approached them. After the shooting, Whitthorne and the woman fled to a friend’s apartment and then to Cleveland, where the Northeast Ohio Violent Fugitive Task Force arrested Whitthorne. Officers recovered a Glock 40 that matched the shell casings at the scene, according to the prosecutors’ news release cited by the Beacon Journal.
At Tuesday’s sentencing, Robinson’s father, Shante Robinson, addressed Whitthorne directly. Shante told the court he had felt like a "ticking time bomb" after his son’s death — a son who, he said, had been searching for a cigarette when he was killed — and that his emotions had swung from anger to confusion before grief counseling began to change him, the Beacon Journal reported. "I had to release control over the situation," Shante said, in remarks reported by the Beacon Journal.
Before leaving the podium, Shante turned and stared at Whitthorne, looking for remorse, the Beacon Journal reported. "Don’t look like there’s none. No apology. No empathy. It’s a shame," Shante said, according to the Beacon Journal. Robinson’s grandmother, Toni Beasley, told the court she had once wanted Whitthorne to die the way her grandson died, but no longer did: "I wanted him to be in front of a wall with a blindfold on," Beasley said, in remarks reported by the Beacon Journal. "Now, I don’t want that revenge killing. I’m now looking for life in prison." Robinson’s sister, Kashmere Caffie, described her younger brother to the Beacon Journal’s reporter as "the most caring person" who would give away the jacket on his back.
What we know — and what we’re still waiting on
What is confirmed: the jury’s guilty verdicts on murder, felony murder, felonious assault, a weapons charge and three firearm specifications; Judge Towell’s life sentence with parole eligibility after 27 years; and the prosecution’s account of the September 25, 2025 shooting, the surveillance footage and the recovered firearm matching the shell casings — all as reported by the Akron Beacon Journal from the court proceedings and the prosecutors’ news release. What remains open is the appeal Whitthorne’s lawyers say is coming, and with it any appellate ruling on the verdict.
Whitthorne maintained his innocence at sentencing and plans to appeal, the Beacon Journal reported. He was represented by defense attorneys Edam Konturas, Seneca Konturas and Chris Rivero. "My client is obviously emotional. He has been wrongfully convicted," Rivero told the court, according to the Beacon Journal. Whitthorne himself apologized to the family for their loss while denying he was the shooter: "I want to apologize for what you all are going through," he said, in remarks reported by the Beacon Journal. "I’m not the person who did it, though. Don’t give up on justice."
The sentence closes the trial-court chapter of a case that began with a body found in the grass off Rosemary Boulevard more than a year ago and a manhunt that ended in Cleveland. For Robinson’s family, Tuesday’s hearing was the first time they could address the man convicted of the killing face to face — and their remarks, moving between fury and forgiveness, filled the record the judge considered before imposing the life term.
What happens next: Whitthorne begins serving the life sentence, with his first parole eligibility after 27 years, while his defense team files the appeal Rivero announced in court. Any appeal would go to Ohio’s Ninth District Court of Appeals, which would review the trial record from Summit County Common Pleas Court.
Photo: Mark Phillips, CC BY


