A Hamilton County judge has awarded more than $98 million to a woman who was sexually assaulted in her Cincinnati home in 1989 by an attacker whose identity stayed unknown for 35 years, the Cincinnati Enquirer reported.
Hamilton County Common Pleas Judge Christopher McDowell awarded Dana Beatty $98,251,966 in her civil lawsuit against Frederick Tanzer, a former doctor — $48,251,966 in compensatory damages and $50 million in punitive damages, according to the Enquirer.
Beatty was assaulted in her Columbia-Tusculum home in 1989 by a masked attacker, the Enquirer reported. She filed the lawsuit last year, after Tanzer was identified and arrested, and testified at a hearing on November 17, 2026.
At that hearing, Beatty testified that 37 years later she still experiences weekly panic attacks, sleep problems, and intrusive recollections, the Enquirer reported. McDowell cited an attack lasting more than five hours, the terror inflicted, and “the severity and permanence of her psychological injuries,” the Enquirer reported.
The identification, when it finally came, was the product of modern forensic work on an old crime. Tanzer was identified when DNA from a coffee cup he threw in the trash matched DNA from the 1989 crime scene, according to the Enquirer. During the attack, the Enquirer reported, he wore a black full-body spandex suit and a mask and did not speak — and he was then married to Beatty’s best friend.
Tanzer could not be charged with rape because of the statute of limitations in place at the time, the Enquirer reported. He pleaded guilty in January to lying to federal agents and is serving a 15-year prison sentence. His medical license has been permanently revoked after more than 30 years of practicing in multiple states, according to the Enquirer.
Tanzer was not in court on November 17, 2026, had no attorney, and did not respond to the summary-judgment motion, the Enquirer reported. He has claimed indigence. Beatty’s attorney, Jeff Kenney, told the Cincinnati Enquirer the lawsuit “was not about money,” and the legal team does not expect to collect much of the judgment.
The size of the award places the case among the largest civil judgments in Hamilton County in recent memory, and it lands in the same week Ohio courts were closing other long-running cases — including a Franklin County sentencing NewsForce247 covered in Lake County Man Gets Probation in Fatal Columbus Stabbing, No Prison Time.
What we know — and what we’re still waiting on: What is confirmed, per the Cincinnati Enquirer’s reporting, is the judgment amount and its breakdown, the November 17, 2026, hearing testimony, and Tanzer’s federal prison sentence. What is not known is whether any meaningful part of the $98 million judgment will ever be collected, given Tanzer’s claim of indigence.
What happens next: Tanzer has 30 days from November 17, 2026, to appeal the judgment, the Enquirer reported.

