Accessibility:
Text size
Thu. Nov 19th, 2026
Ohio voting booth with American flag at a polling locationAn Ohio polling location voting booth. Photo: Tim Evanson, CC BY-SA

A law firm representing Republican candidates in Ohio has asked county boards of elections not to count thousands of provisional ballots cast by voters who moved from one Ohio county to another, the Ohio branches of the League of Women Voters and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) said, according to Democracy Docket. The letters, sent this week — almost two weeks after the November 3, 2026 election — have turned the routine work of counting provisional ballots into a statewide legal fight with at least one Ohio House race hanging in the balance.

The firm at the center of the challenge is the Cincinnati-based Taft Law Firm. In a four-page letter dated November 15, 2026, to the Lucas County Board of Elections, which Democracy Docket obtained, the firm argued that voters who moved counties without updating their registration should not have been allowed to cast a provisional ballot at a polling location at all. Under the firm’s reading of Ohio election law, those voters should have cast their provisional ballots at a board of elections office instead.

"The Board should reject that category of ballots because Ohio law makes the location of casting an express condition of a county-to-county mover’s eligibility to vote in the election," the Taft Law Firm said in its November 15 letter to Lucas County, as quoted by Democracy Docket. The firm warned that its clients "reserve all rights, claims, and objections, including the right to seek relief in court" if the board does not comply.

The Lucas County letter was sent on behalf of Edward Schimmel, the Republican candidate for Ohio House District 44 in the Toledo area. That race remains too close to call: Schimmel led his Democratic opponent, David Fournier, by only 33 votes as of noon on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, according to Democracy Docket. In a race that close, a category of provisional ballots can decide who goes to Columbus.

Advertise your business here

Lucas County, so far, has not complied with the firm’s demand. In a session on Monday, November 16, 2026, Lucas County election board officials said explicitly that provisional ballots cast by voters who moved from another Ohio county can be counted after they are verified, according to WTOL, a CBS-affiliated television station in Toledo, as reported by Democracy Docket. Officials also approved 1,540 provisional ballots cast on Election Day and 835 provisionals cast before Election Day, and rejected another 350 provisionals, Democracy Docket reported.

The League of Women Voters of Ohio and the ACLU of Ohio answered with letters of their own, asking all 88 county boards of elections in Ohio to disregard the Taft requests. Fulfilling the demands, the groups warned, would "violate the First and Fourteenth Amendment rights of the voters in question," according to Democracy Docket. The groups also argued that the voters being challenged followed the state’s own instructions.

That instruction point may be the heart of the dispute. Guidance that Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose sent election officials for this year’s midterms clearly indicated that voters who moved within the state could cast provisional ballots at polling locations, Democracy Docket reported — voters who moved outside their county but stayed in Ohio and did not update their address by the deadline could still cast provisional ballots at polling locations. In its letters, the Taft firm claimed that guidance was incorrect, Democracy Docket reported.

Disenfranchising voters over that disagreement, the League and the ACLU argued, "would amount to disenfranchising thousands of registered Ohio voters en masse for acting in accordance with the express instructions of the Ohio Secretary of State, as relayed through poll workers," according to Democracy Docket. The Taft Law Firm did not respond to Democracy Docket’s request for a response to the voting groups’ letters, Democracy Docket reported.

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on

What we know: the letters were sent, Lucas County’s board has said mover provisionals can be counted once verified, and the District 44 margin was 33 votes at noon Wednesday. What we are still waiting on is how many counties received Taft letters and how many ballots are challenged in total — the voting groups say "thousands," but no county-by-county count has been published — and whether any board changes course or any candidate goes to court. Three other Ohio House races also remain too close to call, Democracy Docket reported, in an election where Democrats broke the Republican supermajority in the Ohio House by flipping at least eight seats.

The fight lands in the middle of the certification calendar that NewsForce247 has been following county by county, from Licking County’s 59.47 percent turnout to Lake County’s 66.06 percent turnout, with boards across Ohio required to certify results by November 24, 2026. Provisional-ballot decisions made this week will be baked into those certified numbers.

What happens next runs on two tracks. County boards will finish their official canvasses and certify by November 24, 2026, and any candidate who believes a category of ballots was wrongly counted or rejected can seek relief in court, as the Taft letters threatened. NewsForce247 will follow the Lucas County count and the District 44 race until a winner is certified.

Photo: Tim Evanson, CC BY-SA

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *