Quick Takeaways
- Stark Library executive director and chief executive officer (CEO) Mary Ellen Icaza is resigning after seven years, with her last day on January 16, 2027.
- Senior director Jennifer Welsh takes over as interim leader on January 17, 2027, while the board starts a successor search.
- The board is studying three levy options for the May 4, 2027 primary ballot after voters narrowly rejected a renewal plus increase on November 3, 2026.
Stark Library is heading into a leadership change and a second levy decision at the same time. Mary Ellen Icaza, the library system’s executive director and CEO since 2018, told the board she has accepted a position elsewhere and will step down, with her last day on January 16, 2027, The Repository reported. The board approved her resignation at its November 17, 2026 meeting, two weeks after Stark County voters narrowly rejected the library’s levy request.
Icaza declined to name her new employer or her new role, The Repository reported, and said further details would come in a later statement from the library. Board Vice President Susan Rodgers praised her tenure at the meeting. “It’s been a pleasure and an honor to have her as our CEO. And she will be greatly missed. Obviously, we wish her the very best,” Rodgers said, according to The Repository.
An interim leader from inside the system
After meeting in executive session for about 75 minutes on November 17, 2026, the board voted unanimously to appoint Jennifer Welsh, the library’s senior director of public services, as interim CEO and executive director effective January 17, 2027, The Repository reported. Welsh will receive an annual salary of $142,971. She knows the system from the branch level up: she has served as the library’s community libraries director, as a children’s librarian, as manager of the Lake Township branch, and as main library manager. It is not yet clear what process the board will use to search for a permanent successor.
Why the levy failed, and what it pays for
The money question hanging over the change is the November 3, 2026 levy defeat. About 50.25 percent of voters rejected a renewal of the library’s 2-mill levy with a 0.3-mill increase, The Repository reported. Collections under the current 2-mill levy run through 2027. Property owners now pay about $44 a year for every $100,000 of home valuation; the rejected increase would have raised that by $11, to $55 a year per $100,000.
The increase would have lifted the library’s property tax revenue from about $12.3 million a year to about $15 million a year, according to The Repository. About 40 percent of the library’s roughly $22 million in annual revenue comes from Ohio’s Public Library Fund. Icaza had argued the library, which has 193 employees, needed the added revenue to maintain services against rising costs for employee health insurance, books and materials, security, property insurance, and bookmobile repairs. The state also cut Stark Library’s Public Library Fund support by $350,000 a year from 2025 to 2026. Icaza said the library has not yet made any decisions on cuts to services because of the defeat, The Repository reported.
Three options for a May 4, 2027 return to voters
The board is not waiting to respond. At the same November 17, 2026 meeting, trustees voted unanimously on three resolutions that start the process of putting another levy request on the May 4, 2027 primary ballot, The Repository reported. The board asked the Stark County auditor to certify how much revenue each of three possible issues would raise and what each would cost taxpayers: a renewal of the current 2-mill levy with no increase; a renewal plus a 0.2-mill increase; or a renewal plus the same 0.3-mill increase voters just rejected.
“We haven’t made a decision what we’re doing yet,” fiscal officer Chris Butler said, according to The Repository. “So we have picked those three options to give us flexibility.” Icaza added, “We don’t have a crystal ball. So we’re trying to plan as best as possible,” The Repository reported. The board expects to choose one option after the auditor’s certified figures arrive by December 2026. Stark County commissioners would then have to approve placing the issue on the May 4, 2027 ballot by the February 3, 2027 filing deadline.
Only voters in the Canton, Canton South, Osnaburg, Fairless, Lake, Jackson, Plain, Perry, Sandy Valley, and Tuslaw school districts vote on a Stark Library levy, The Repository noted. The North Canton, Rodman (Alliance), Louisville, Massillon, Canal Fulton, and Minerva public libraries are independent systems serving the county’s other districts. Library leadership is in transition elsewhere in Ohio, too: a longtime Ross County library director retired in Chillicothe, and the Cuyahoga County library system disclosed a vendor data breach this week.
What Icaza leaves behind
Icaza’s tenure reshaped the system’s buildings. Under her leadership, Stark Library built and opened a new Jackson Township branch, renovated several branches, acquired its current operations center on Cleveland Avenue Northwest, demolished its old main library building, and began construction on a new downtown Canton location scheduled for completion in 2028, The Repository reported. “I believe the board will continue working with the staff to ensure the library moves forward,” Icaza said, according to The Repository.
What happens next comes in stages: the auditor’s levy figures by December 2026, a board choice among the three options, Icaza’s final day on January 16, 2027, Welsh’s interim start the next day, and a commissioners’ decision on the ballot issue by February 3, 2027.
Photo: The Frank T. Bow Federal Building in downtown Canton, Ohio. Photo: Niagara66, CC BY-SA


