Accessibility:
Text size
Wed. Nov 18th, 2026
Nationwide Arena in Columbus, Ohio, the home of the Columbus Blue Jackets, seen from the streetNationwide Arena in Columbus, Ohio. Photo: Eric, CC BY-SA

Quick Takeaways

  • New York defenseman Matthew Schaefer scored his first career hat trick as the Islanders beat the Columbus Blue Jackets 5-1 on Tuesday night, November 17, 2026, in Elmont, New York.
  • Zach Werenski scored the only Columbus goal; the Blue Jackets (7-12-0) have lost five straight games in regulation.
  • Columbus goaltender Cam Talbot made 36 saves, but the Blue Jackets were shut out until the third period.

Matthew Schaefer scored his first career hat trick for the New York Islanders in a 5-1 win against the Columbus Blue Jackets at UBS Arena on Tuesday night, November 17, 2026, NHL.com reported. Schaefer is the third defenseman in Islanders history to record a hat trick, and the first since Denis Potvin on March 4, 1982, according to NHL.com.

Anthony Duclair and Tony DeAngelo each had a goal and an assist, and Mathew Barzal had two assists for the Islanders (10-6-4), who have won three straight games and outscored their opponents 16-5 in that span, NHL.com reported. Ilya Sorokin made 28 saves for New York.

Zach Werenski scored the lone goal for the Blue Jackets (7-12-0), who have lost five straight games in regulation, NHL.com reported. Cam Talbot made 36 saves for Columbus.

The scoring opened late in the first period. Duclair gave the Islanders a 1-0 lead on a power play at 19:02 of the first, taking a return feed from Barzal and beating Talbot glove side from the high slot, NHL.com reported. Schaefer doubled the lead to 2-0 at 1:34 of the second period, scoring glove side on a prone Talbot.

Werenski cut the lead to 2-1 at 1:12 of the third period, skating past Ryan Pulock down the left wing, cutting across the crease and sliding a backhand under Sorokin’s right pad, NHL.com reported. Schaefer responded at 7:01 to make it 3-1, shoveling a Pulock rebound into an open net with his backhand; the Blue Jackets challenged the play for goaltender interference, but the call on the ice was confirmed after a video review, according to NHL.com.

DeAngelo extended the lead to 4-1 at 11:52, roofing a backhand high over Talbot’s blocker, and Schaefer completed the hat trick by shooting into an empty net at 16:08 for the 5-1 final, NHL.com reported.

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on

What we know: Columbus has lost five straight in regulation and sits at 7-12-0, and its offense produced one goal on Tuesday after being held scoreless for two periods. What is still open: how the Blue Jackets adjust a structure that, in assistant coach Don Granato’s words to NHL.com, broke down again in the second period. “We got away from our structure again,” Granato told NHL.com. “When you go into someone’s building, you have to respect the process. We didn’t have a great start. We were able to stay in it. We turned some momentum back, and then some decisions in the second period, it just allowed the game to open up and get excitement and energy in this building for them. We allowed that.”

Werenski pointed to the same problem from the ice. “That’s the exact start to a third period we want,” Werenski told NHL.com. “We get on the board there, I feel like we had some momentum. Third one is tough. Still in it, you know? Then fourth one obviously feels like the game’s a little bit out of reach. But yeah, I mean, it’s one of those things where we give ourselves really no room for error. Some nights we’re only scoring one goal or having no goals going into the third period.”

Schaefer’s night also rewrote the record book for teenage defensemen. He has six career multigoal games, passing Phil Housley (five) for the most by a teenage defenseman in National Hockey League (NHL) history, and his 17 multipoint games are tied with Ray Bourque for the second most by a teenage defenseman, behind Housley’s 34, NHL.com reported. He has 10 points (five goals, five assists) during a six-game point streak.

The loss lands in a busy week for Ohio’s other teams in the national spotlight, with the Cleveland Browns flexed into Sunday Night Football against the Raiders on November 29 and Ohio State climbing six spots to No. 14 in the College Football Playoff rankings.

Advertise your business here

What happens next: the Blue Jackets’ immediate task is stopping a five-game regulation losing streak that has dropped them to 7-12-0, and finding goals earlier in games — Tuesday’s only score came after two scoreless periods, a pattern Werenski told NHL.com the team has to fix.

Photo: Eric, CC BY-SA

By Derek Malone

Derek Malone is NewsForce247's Sports Director. His byline covers Ohio's college and professional teams — the Buckeyes, Browns, Bengals, Cavaliers, Guardians, Reds, Blue Jackets, and Crew.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *