Quick Takeaways
• A Cuyahoga County judge has dismissed U.S. Rep. Max Miller’s defamation lawsuit against his ex-wife, Emily Moreno, finding her allegation that he once doused her with hot water to be “substantially true,” USA Today reported.
• Judge Joy Kennedy dismissed the case with prejudice on November 16, 2026, and ordered Miller to pay about $77,000 toward Moreno’s attorney’s fees, according to USA Today’s report of the decision.
• Miller, a Republican who lost his re-election bid on November 3, 2026, has denied wrongdoing and has not been criminally charged; he can appeal the dismissal.
A Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas judge has thrown out the defamation lawsuit that outgoing U.S. Rep. Max Miller filed against his ex-wife, Emily Moreno, concluding that Moreno’s allegation that Miller once doused her with hot water is “substantially true,” USA Today reported. Judge Joy Kennedy dismissed the case on November 16, 2026, in a decision that also found no credible evidence that Moreno was responsible for the news article that detailed her allegations.
Miller filed the lawsuit in May 2026 after the Daily Mail published an article detailing Moreno’s domestic abuse allegations against him, USA Today reported. Miller argued that Moreno leaked the allegations to damage his re-election campaign and influence a custody dispute involving the couple’s young daughter. Miller and Moreno married in August 2022, had a daughter in November 2023 and divorced in June 2025, according to the Washington Post’s account of the case, as reported by other outlets.
In her decision, Kennedy wrote, “Construing the evidence in the light of most favorable to Plaintiff, the Court finds that there is no credible evidence in support of Plaintiff’s claims against Defendant Moreno,” according to USA Today’s report of the ruling. On the central allegation, the judge wrote that Miller “has not shown that the statement about dousing Defendant Moreno with boiling hot water are false,” and that “the imputation that Plaintiff poured or doused Defendant Moreno with hot water is substantially true,” USA Today reported.
Spectrum News reported that Kennedy also cited an audio recording in which Moreno confronted Miller about pouring hot water on her, and that Miller denied pouring the water on her neck but admitted an incident occurred. The judge found no credible evidence that Moreno leaked the story or acted with actual malice, the legal standard a public figure must meet to prove defamation, Spectrum News reported.
The dismissal was granted under Ohio’s anti-SLAPP law — the Uniform Public Expression Protection Act — which Moreno’s legal team invoked in asking the court for expedited dismissal, according to reports of the ruling. Because Kennedy dismissed the case with prejudice, Miller cannot refile the same claims. She ordered Miller to pay court costs and about $77,000 toward Moreno’s attorney’s fees and expenses, USA Today reported.
The ruling lands two weeks after Miller lost his bid for re-election on November 3, 2026, in Ohio’s 7th Congressional District, a campaign that was roiled over the summer when Moreno’s allegations surfaced, USA Today reported. The legal fight has run alongside the broader post-election reshaping of Ohio politics that NewsForce247 has been covering, from House Republicans renominating Matt Huffman as speaker after election losses shrank their majority to more than a dozen central Ohio candidates facing fines over election-law violations.
Miller has repeatedly denied any wrongdoing and has not been criminally charged in connection with Moreno’s allegations, USA Today reported. The civil ruling addresses only whether Miller could prove his defamation and false-light claims against Moreno; it is not a criminal finding. Reports of the decision noted that a separate federal civil-rights lawsuit connected to the couple’s custody dispute remains pending.
What we know — and what we’re still waiting on
What is confirmed, from Judge Kennedy’s November 16, 2026, decision as reported by USA Today and Spectrum News: the defamation and false-light claims are dismissed with prejudice; the court found no credible evidence supporting Miller’s claims, found the hot-water allegation substantially true, and ordered Miller to pay court costs and about $77,000 toward Moreno’s attorney’s fees. What is still open: whether Miller appeals the dismissal, and how the separate pending federal case connected to the custody dispute is resolved.
What happens next: Miller may appeal Kennedy’s dismissal to Ohio’s Eighth District Court of Appeals. Moreno is the daughter of U.S. Sen. Bernie Moreno of Ohio. Miller’s term in the U.S. House runs until his successor takes office in January 2027.


