Special Weather Statement for Franklin County until 9:00 AM ET — see the details
Tue. Nov 17th, 2026
Downtown Worthington, Ohio, in winterDowntown Worthington, Ohio (public domain)

Worthington City Council voted unanimously on Monday, Nov. 16, to move an extra $140,000 into the city’s water fund to help pay for water main break repairs after the Columbus suburb weathered 35 breaks in 2025, The Columbus Dispatch reported.

The 7-0 vote adds the transfer on top of the $200,000 Worthington had already appropriated for 2025 water main break repairs in its 2026 city budget, according to The Columbus Dispatch. The city of Columbus, which provides water to many of its suburban neighbors, repaired the Worthington breaks as they occurred, and Worthington must pay Columbus for repairs once the number of breaks passes a threshold set by the two cities’ agreement.

In 2025 that threshold was 18 breaks. Worthington had 35, so the city owes Columbus for the remaining 17 breaks at a total cost of around $331,400, The Columbus Dispatch reported.

The bill is the largest of its kind the city has faced. The amount Worthington has to pay for water main breaks varies widely by year, from a low of $9,317 in 2019 for 2018 repairs to the high of $331,401 for 2025 repairs, according to a city staff memo cited by The Columbus Dispatch.

That swing is exactly why the city pays as it goes instead of budgeting the money up front, Worthington Finance Director Scott Barter told the council, The Columbus Dispatch reported. “We don’t want to commit funds to be restricted out of the general fund in years … that we aren’t sure we’re going to have those breaks,” Barter said, in remarks reported by The Columbus Dispatch.

The drivers are underground and seasonal. Worthington’s breaks are driven by cold weather, freeze-and-thaw cycles and the city’s aging water lines, City Manager Robyn Stewart said, according to The Columbus Dispatch. “It’s not unusual after, when you have a particularly cold winter, to experience more impacts to your water lines,” Stewart said, in remarks reported by The Columbus Dispatch.

And 2026 is not giving the system a rest. Worthington has already seen another increase in water main breaks this year, and the city plans to allocate more money in its 2027 budget to pay for them, The Columbus Dispatch reported.

Worthington’s arrangement is the mirror image of the fight playing out in Cincinnati, where NewsForce247 reported Monday that water bills could rise from $32.81 to $51.69 by 2031 under a proposed Greater Cincinnati Water Works increase. In Cincinnati the argument is over rates charged to more than a million customers; in Worthington it is over a repair bill passed between two cities under a standing agreement — but in both places, aging pipes and rising repair costs are landing on local budgets.

What we know — and what we’re still waiting on

What is confirmed, from The Columbus Dispatch’s report of the Nov. 16 meeting: council voted 7-0 to transfer $140,000 from the general fund to the water fund; Worthington recorded 35 water main breaks in 2025 against an 18-break threshold in its agreement with Columbus; the resulting bill is about $331,400, the highest in the years the staff memo covered; and breaks are already up again in 2026. What is still ahead is the size of the 2027 budget allocation the city says it will make, and whether this winter’s freeze-and-thaw cycles push the break count higher still.

What happens next is budget season: Worthington folds a larger water-main repair figure into its 2027 budget, while Columbus continues billing repairs as they happen under the two cities’ agreement.

By Scott Merritt

Scott Merritt is NewsForce247's general assignment reporter for Central Ohio, covering Columbus, Marion, and the fast-growing counties at the state's center.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *