Ohio high school sports could be headed for its biggest structural change in decades. The Suburban League submitted a petition to the Ohio High School Athletic Association on Monday, Nov. 16, carrying 152 signatures from high school principals — more than double the 75 required — asking the OHSAA membership to vote on holding separate state tournaments for public and private schools, according to Stateline Sports Network, which reported the filing was first reported by WCPO 9 in Cincinnati.
The petition asks for a membership vote in May 2027. If the question reaches the ballot and passes, separate public and non-public tournaments would begin with the 2028-29 school year, Stateline Sports Network reported. The filing arrived two weeks ahead of the petition’s Dec. 1 deadline.
Under the proposal, a new bylaw 2-2-1 would classify every member school as either Public — traditional district schools and community or charter schools — or Non-Public — chartered and nonchartered private schools — for tournament competition only. Schools in both groups would remain OHSAA members, according to Stateline Sports Network. The OHSAA’s competitive balance system, which adjusts enrollment figures in football, basketball, soccer, volleyball, softball and baseball, would end after the 2027-28 school year under the proposal.
The numbers behind the drive are stark. The OHSAA has 812 member high schools — 691 public and 121 private, meaning private schools make up under 15 percent of the membership — and the petition’s own presentation to administrators states that private schools won 36 of the 98 team state titles awarded in 2025-26, Stateline Sports Network reported, citing the petitioners’ presentation. That title figure comes from the petitioners themselves and has not been independently verified.
“We’re just looking for equity throughout high school sports,” Nordonia athletic director Rob Eckenrode, one of the petition-drive leaders, told the Akron Beacon Journal. “There’s plenty of recruiting bylaws in place for the OHSAA. We just want them all to be abided by. Unfortunately, people are not playing by the same rules. It’s either split or everybody abides by the same rules.” Eckenrode also told the Akron Beacon Journal: “Less than 15% of OHSAA member are private schools. Private schools are still making up 35% of state champions.”
The drive was organized by superintendents, principals and athletic directors from the Suburban League — Aurora, Barberton, Brecksville-Broadview Heights, Copley, Highland, Hudson, Kenston, North Royalton, Nordonia, Mayfield, Medina, Revere, Solon, Stow-Munroe Falls and Twinsburg. Every league school is involved except Wadsworth, which specifically asked not to be included, according to Stateline Sports Network and the Akron Beacon Journal.
Only principals can sign an OHSAA petition, and the rules require at least 75 signatures with at least five from each of the association’s six athletic districts. The OHSAA must still verify the 152 signatures — including whether the five-per-district minimum is met in every district — before the question is placed on the ballot, Stateline Sports Network reported. Whether the signatures satisfy the district minimum has not yet been confirmed.
The association itself is staying neutral for now. OHSAA Executive Director Doug Ute has said the OHSAA office is not taking a position on the petition, according to Stateline Sports Network. “The petition itself is not the vote, which would take place next May if they get enough signatures,” OHSAA spokesman Tim Stried said in a statement quoted by Stateline Sports Network. “If the vote becomes imminent, the OHSAA will release more information and explain what separate tournaments would mean, including potential unintended consequences.”
Reaction on the private-school side has been cautious. Summit County private schools Hoban and Walsh Jesuit withheld comment until the petition was formalized, while CVCA and St. Vincent-St. Mary did not respond, the Akron Beacon Journal reported. Norton athletic director Travis Dobbins told the Akron Beacon Journal he has “mixed emotions” about the proposal and worries private schools could leave the OHSAA and form their own organization if the split passes.
Ohio has been here before. Similar public-private split referendums failed in 1978 and 1993, and a Wayne County push about a decade ago led instead to the competitive balance system adopted in 2017, according to Stateline Sports Network. This time, the petitioners cleared the signature threshold with room to spare — the question is whether the full membership agrees.
What we know — and what we’re still waiting on: Confirmed: the petition was filed Nov. 16 with 152 principal signatures, per Stateline Sports Network and WCPO 9’s reporting. Still open: whether the OHSAA’s verification finds at least five valid signatures from each of the six districts, and how member schools across Ohio — public and private — will campaign ahead of a vote that is still six months away.
What happens next is verification. If the OHSAA confirms the signatures, the question goes on the association’s annual referendum ballot, with voting running May 1-15, 2027 — one vote per member school, cast by its principal. Passage would take effect with the 2028-29 school year.
Photo: SilentMatt Psychedelic, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons


