SANDUSKY, Ohio — A developer wants to transform the former Value City Furniture store in downtown Sandusky into a mixed-use hub with 14,000 square feet of first-floor commercial space and 32 residential apartments, according to a proposal reported by StayTunedSandusky.
City planning staff is recommending the Sandusky City Commission approve the proposed site plan to redevelop the property at 202 E. Market St., and the commission could take up the proposal as soon as Nov. 23, StayTunedSandusky reported. The redevelopment spans five adjacent parcels — the former retail building, loading docks, existing parking, and two houses, according to the Sandusky Division of Planning & Zoning.
North Coast Design Build, a Sheffield Lake developer, has the property under option from owner SSC Market St Sandusky, LLC — an affiliate of Columbus-based Schottenstein Property Group, the long-term owners of the property and the Value City franchise, according to StayTunedSandusky.
The plan would return a large, vacant retail box to daily use in the heart of downtown. A first floor of commercial space topped by 32 apartments follows the pattern Sandusky has used across its downtown revival: ground-floor businesses that draw foot traffic, with residents upstairs who support them year-round, not just in the summer tourist season.
Downtown housing has been a recurring theme in the city’s recent decisions. The commission recently approved a major pivot for the Osborne School renovation project, shifting that historic building from rental apartments toward condominium homes. The Value City proposal would add a larger block of apartments in a single project, on a Market Street site that has sat as a reminder of the chain-store era since the furniture store closed.
Because the site plan needs commission approval, the Nov. 23 meeting is the decision point to watch. Planning staff’s recommendation gives the proposal momentum, but commissioners will weigh the details of the five-parcel assembly — including what happens to the two houses included in the footprint — before any work can begin.
What happens next: the Sandusky City Commission could take up the site plan as soon as its Nov. 23 meeting. If the plan is approved, North Coast Design Build would still need to close on its option and complete the city’s permitting process before construction starts.
Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA

